IMDb > El otro (2007) > IMDb user comments

IMDb user comments for
El otro (2007) More at IMDbPro »

Filter: Hide Spoilers:
Index 8 comments in total 

6 out of 6 people found the following comment useful :-
Deep and sensible, 26 July 2008
8/10
Author: elinagoni from Uruguay

I think this is a film about life, the passing of time and getting older. It is a slow moving film, not much dialog and little action.But this is necessary to get you into the situation. Juan is a middle-age man who notices that he is getting old (he cannot see without glasses anymore). At the same time his wife is pregnant and his father is dying. These facts lead him to a journey throughout his life, an inside journey. "The other" is the man that he is not any longer, or the one that he is never going to be (other professions, other backgrounds).Life, death and time. The film is simple in appearance: Juan takes a bus and walks along the streets, meets different people, changes his name, etc. but it invites you to feel and understand his experience, that is human experience. Juan is very well performed by Julio Chávez and the characters look like people in a dream. In fact, I think that if it would have been a dream it wouldn't make any difference. i do not recommend this film to very young people, of those who like action and a clear argument. It is a film for people in the forties who like to think and discuss about important things in life.

Was the above comment useful to you?

3 out of 3 people found the following comment useful :-
Psyhological drama, 1 October 2008
10/10
Author: Alexander Werner from Canada

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

This is a deeply psychological drama, free from any action. Slow movement with separate episodes forming a puzzle.

Subtly and from various episodes, the movie constructs a picture of a man, who at some point was abandoned by his mom, and his dad became and remains his only real affection. The son barely speaks to his mom. The affection father - son is mutual and exclusive for anybody else, even for girlfriends/wife. Some females do appear in the picture, but they do not have his love extended to them, even after intimacies take place.

The father is sick, and the son is emotionally engrossed into the thinking of death. He runs away from an evening in the bar. He comes to the funeral of a stranger he met on the bus to see how it looks like to be dead. He rents hotel rooms under the names of deceased men, and nobody comes to question him - because those men are already forgotten! He still wants to fight death, even when the dying person is an old lady, not particularly attractive while unconsciously spread on her bed in her underwear. The hero is disgusted by the view, but performs CPR and saves her life.

The final exchange - a small number of words - serves as a key to the whole movie.

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 1 people found the following comment useful :-
What do you think?, 12 February 2009
8/10
Author: jpschapira from Argentina

I'm thinking maybe "Cordero de Dios" and "La mujer sin cabeza", two of the most important Argentinean films of last year, may have taken a bit of inspiration from "El otro", writer/director Ariel Rotter's tale of desperation and loneliness. The visual search, with accentuated and well framed still cameras, the apparent nothingness of the events that take place (usually confused with the term 'boring'), speak well of Rotter-in terms of a filmmaker with something to say- and recall the movies previously mentioned.

But the visual search here is clearer than in "Cordero de Dios" and the situation that leads to the 'journey' of the protagonist, Juan (Juio Chávez), is less specified than in "La mujer sin cabeza". In both aspects, "El otro" seems to be a riskier picture; a picture that is less willing to help the viewer solve its mysteries. And when I say 'journey' I mean not only the journey we see Juan experience on screen but also the one he's living inside; and don't forget a journey of the senses for the viewer…A journey where the viewer is obliged to think.

Suddenly Juan, an apparently calm lawyer, seems to run away from the comfort of his daily life. He finds out his wife's pregnant, he arrives home and we see him staring at her feet (an image that's recurrent throughout the film); then he visits his sick father (Osvaldo Bonet) and tells him he'll not be with him the next day because of a business trip. When we see Juan on the bus before leaving, he looks sweaty and tired. If you pay attention, you may conclude he's scared.

And the journey begins. Why? How is it possible? Is there something more than the sudden news? With the car crash suffered by Vero (María Onetto, who also plays a small role here), Lucrecia Martel made it easier for the viewer, delivering something/somewhere precise to depart from, and showing us her inner circle of people. About Juan we know nothing, and it's to Rotter's credit that we follow the actions of this boring-and maybe bored-man with a lot of interest for more than an hour.

I was never quite sure where Juan went for his business trip, but the movie doesn't want us to know about that particular place and its people. The only thing the movie wants from that place is that it appears as virtually deserted and has something appealing enough so Juan decides to stay for more than one day. The rest is improvisation, or it may all be a dream. Sudden convenient deaths, beautiful improbable women, two or more hotels (also virtually deserted), Juan walking in the dark night with his black suit: his fear, our fear. The morning: peace.

With this title role, Julio Chavéz completes the 'silence' trilogy started with "Extraño" and "El custodio". Far away from the pretentious objectives of the first film, and with a lot of more room to talk than in the second one, Chávez finds in Juan a natural balance and exploits it achieving the best performance of the three. Some elements are the same (we are never sure of who the man is, what his intentions are and, of course, the silence), but the director's concept is more well-rounded than in the previous pieces and it comes to light in the actor's work.

Let's never forget that cinema is many things, and making us think can't be something to underestimate. When Juan is all by himself at a funeral, without knowing exactly why he's there; when he's standing watching the coffin in his black suit, I thought about a chapter in Albert Camus' "L'Etranger". There, the main character expressed his inside thoughts of how he felt in a similar situation.

I think Juan was saying those same things, or maybe not. What do you think?

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 5 people found the following comment useful :-
Very Boring and Depressing Film, 4 July 2008
2/10
Author: juanmv from Buenos Aires, Argentina

I just finished watching "El Otro". I have always taken my hat off to Julio Chavez's performances, as he is a great actor, but this movie is really depressing and slow. I guess that it would have been even worse if it wasn't for Julio. Anyways, this is definitely a film that you will never understand if you are not from Argentina, and even if you are, I would advise you not to rent this movie in order to have a nice time with your girlfriend, boyfriend, family or friends... it is really depressing and incredibly slow, and the plot does not make a lot of sense neither. Probably the director wanted to show the fragility of the human life, but what he does is bore and impress the audience with scenes that shock you a little bit. It gives you something to think about, but not in a good way. Overall, I definitely didn't like this movie.

Was the above comment useful to you?

9 out of 21 people found the following comment useful :-
Disappointing, 15 May 2007
3/10
Author: fontaine_d from Canada

I just came back from "El Otro" playing here in Buenos Aires and I have to say I was very disappointed. The film is very slow moving (don't get me wrong, I enjoy slow moving films!), slow to the point of driving you crazy. All you hear is Julio Chavez breathing heavily throughout the whole film. This is a poorly made film, but more importantly, it is a film without a lick of inspiration, I felt nothing for the story or its characters.

"El Otro" was made only for the sake of making a film... making it forgetful. I would advise you to pass on this one, if you want to see good Argentinian films, look for films by Sorin.

Was the above comment useful to you?

0 out of 4 people found the following comment useful :-
Horrible, 4 August 2008
1/10
Author: diba23 from United States

*** This comment may contain spoilers ***

Guy walking around without motive... I will never get those two hours of my life back. The guy kept on assuming identities and cheating on his pregnant wife. What was I thinking? How did this win a price anywhere? I understood he loved his father but other than that the movie was completely senseless to me. What was the purpose of walking so much and going to the funeral of a stranger for no apparent reason. How did this enrich his life??? Why did we have to see the dying old lady on her underwear????!!! Why???!!!!

I though it would be deep or about something more interesting. I do not recommend the movie even to leave on while sleeping...

Was the above comment useful to you?

2 out of 9 people found the following comment useful :-
Bad movie, 10 March 2008
1/10
Author: miag3 from United States

The title should have been "The walker". That was only he did walk.

There was nothing on the movie that was good. The description of the movie doesn't really comply with the plot.

The only thing that I can get from the movie is that he was a good son, but a low life terrible person.

I'm sorry that I expend my money and time, on this movie. I saw people leaving the theater in the middle of the movie. I stayed hoping that it will better....what a mistake. I got worse.

If there is a suggestion that I can make to he producer is to re-direct his life to another field, because making movies is definitely no his cup of tea

Was the above comment useful to you?

1 out of 9 people found the following comment useful :-
A waste if time, 6 March 2008
1/10
Author: jogares from United States

The title should have been the walker. The guy expend 90% of the movie walking. He doesn't know what he wants, or what he is. Go through life stealing peoples identity for nothing. He gets no benefit, no money, nothing pretending to be another person.

No body was able to understand why he was pretending to be somebody else.

The only thing that was clear in this movie is that he love his father and was a good son. But the rest was crap.

May be director is a looser that would like to be somebody else. But what he really should do is to get a real job, because after his movie, I don't think he has a chance to make as a movie producer.

Was the above comment useful to you?

Add another comment

Related Links

Ratings Awards External reviews
Official site Plot keywords Main details
Your user comments Your vote history